Nintendo is commonly viewed as a master of vertical integration. From console manufacturing to software development, Nintendo orchestrates the entire process in-house. Companies with this degree of creative control are few and far between, putting Nintendo in a category with behemoths like Disney.
The Glaring Exception: Pokémon
But, there exists one glaring outlier to this rule. According to numerous reports, Pokémon ranks as Nintendo's most lucrative franchise. Some figures, albeit hard to verify, claim it is the highest-grossing media franchise of all time. This wealth flows from ubiquitous merchandise, game sales, and a thriving card game business. Surprisingly, Nintendo does not fully control the Pokémon universe.
Nintendo manages the publishing of the primary Pokémon titles, yet the creative work is done by the separate company Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the entity behind the trading card game), Nintendo is a part-owner of The Pokémon Company. This entity oversees the global licensing empire that brings in multibillions. Furthermore, the enormous hit Pokémon Go was created and launched by external companies under a agreement from The Pokémon Company, operating at a significant remove from Nintendo's immediate supervision.
In fact, the phenomenal rise of Pokémon in the 1990s and early 2000s had a notable forerunner.
In 1989, Nintendo released the revolutionary Game Boy. But, its internal designers had not yet found the ideal application for it. That answer came in the shape of the external puzzle game Tetris. Nintendo's determined quest to obtain the licensing for the Game Boy version of Tetris is the stuff of legend in the gaming world. The success of Tetris solidified the Game Boy's position and paved the path for Nintendo's enduring dominance in handheld gaming. This handheld business offered crucial support during difficult periods for its console business and ultimately led to the versatile Switch.
Despite superb ports of its own franchises, a completely groundbreaking portable game failed to be conceived in-house. Rather, that spark originated with ex- writer Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. After discovering that Game Boys could be connected via a cable, he envisioned exchanging digital beings, inspired by his youthful experiences of catching insects.
Nintendo saw the promise in the proposal from Game Freak and provided it the green light. However, it took a long time for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the sprawling role-playing game launched in 1996. Another couple of years passed before the titles, alongside a card game and an animated series, burst into a worldwide craze. Pokémon extended the life of the Game Boy deep into its lengthy reign and essentially secured Nintendo's economic future.
Why Didn't Acquire It All?
It may appear strange that Nintendo did not attempt to fully acquire Game Freak and Pokémon once its massive success became obvious. A more aggressive company would have probably aimed a full takeover. Instead, the tripartite partnership between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was formalized as early as 1998. This developed into The Pokémon Company, which today handles the worldwide franchise.
Nintendo has a tradition of tight-knit, enduring collaborations with chosen independent studios, such as HAL Laboratory and Intelligent Systems, without acquiring them. However, Pokémon's scale was of a different magnitude. So why not seize the whole prize? It is possible that creators Satoshi Tajiri and Tsunekazu Ishihara were not willing to part with their creation. It is also possible that Nintendo's leadership, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the astute Satoru Iwata, made a conscious choice not to pursue complete acquisition.
The Benefits of Separation
Looking back, this setup may have been remarkably shrewd. Would Nintendo have sanctioned the enormous range of licensed goods or ventured into the trading card market with such fervor? The Pokémon Company, functioning with a degree of independence, could pursue a voracious strategy to claim global attention and revenue.
This separation enabled Nintendo to enjoy the financial benefits while staying relatively shielded from the occasional backlashes related to the brand. When concerns arose about the card game's impact, the scrutiny was directed elsewhere from Nintendo. Also, the occasionally mixed reception of modern Game Freak games is a reputational cost mostly borne by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo itself.
A Lasting Symbiosis
Ultimately, this arrangement reflects a core Nintendo trait. The company is known for not tampering with what works.|Nintendo generally avoids unnecessary